Development aid
Development aid: Does helping poorer countries really work?
Balanced since the start. Similar over the last 12 months.
- Since the start (May 2014)3,246 votes51% Pros49% Cons
- Last 5 years2,873 votes52% Pros48% Cons
- Last 12 months505 votes48% Pros52% Cons
- Last 30 days9 votes56% Pros44% Cons
Year by year new votes per year
| Year | New votes, pros and cons | Majority | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 75% Cons | 107 | |
| 2022 | 51% Pros | 533 | |
| 2021 | 53% Pros | 906 | |
| 2020 | 59% Pros | 717 | |
| 2019 | 54% Cons | 290 | |
| 2018 | 53% Cons | 407 | |
| 2017 | 52% Cons | 220 | |
| 2016 | 55% Pros | 42 | |
| 2015 | 79% Cons | 14 | |
| 2014 | 60% Pros | 10 | |
| Total | 51.2% Pros | 3,246 |
Development aid is support that richer countries and organisations give to developing countries, for example money, loans, expertise or projects. This list collects the arguments for and against it.
This list is also available in German: Entwicklungshilfe
- Top post
It helps countries destroyed by war get their economies back on their feet
- Top post
The country relies on aid and becomes dependent on industrialised countries, losing its independence
Helping people to help themselves
Industrialised countries exploit developing countries and their raw materials to make a profit
It provides people with food, education, water and more
Governments of developing countries see financial aid as a steady source of income (corruption, bribery, embezzlement)
We have a global responsibility (our lifestyle is largely based on exploiting developing countries)
National debt increases
Escaping the vicious circle of poverty on your own is hard
Only effective if the measures are sustainable
Education, preparing for the future and more
The money doesn't reach the people
It boosts the economy and enables economic progress in poor countries
They're just after the oil
Recipient countries can't become economically viable again on their own
Seeing the wealth of industrialised countries makes people feel poor and in need of help
Contraception and sex education slow down the spread of HIV and overpopulation
Help is often not accepted (for example, people trust traditional healers more than doctors)
Better transport infrastructure
Aid organisations aren't transparent (it isn't clear exactly where the donations go)
Economic stability and security matter, so that there are fewer reasons to migrate, for example from Africa, and no wave of refugees
Local companies know the structures in the region; international companies don't. Local needs come first, and there is less risk of the project failing.
It helps stop climate change by providing access to climate-friendly energy
Governments always cut it back anyway
Newer and better farming methods improve agriculture
International companies create jobs. With local companies, the profits also stay in the country and are reinvested.
Better basic services
When an attempt to help a country fails, aid organisations often simply pull out of the project and leave damage behind
Every person has the right to as good a life as ours; everyone should live under the same conditions
Money only helps in the short term and reinforces the dependency
A higher standard of living
Chemical fertilisers, for example, reduce soil fertility. When the aid ends, the soil is usually barren.
Development aid creates jobs for aid workers
The people there lack the will to change anything
Cultural exchange
We are not responsible for these people
Microcredits for local small businesses and individuals to become self-employed, which ultimately helps the country's economy grow
Industrialised countries polish their image
A really great initiative
Because nothing is expected in return (countries receive gifts for free), the country's own initiative and willingness to innovate wither away
It reduces inequality within society
High debts, because the money can't always be repaid through exports and imports
Supplies of raw materials
A lot of money doesn't automatically help
With a modest donation, they can support poorer countries that struggle with so many disadvantages in rebuilding, building schools and more
First and foremost, our tax money is gone (always a risk, and you only see results after decades)
There will be more countries that are able to help people
Development aid destroys local markets and production structures
Helping with children's education can never do any harm
More attention goes to the donor than to the developing country
Trade routes
Inequalities
Development is always a good thing, as long as all the capitalists profit from it
The trickle-down effect fails to happen
Giving everyone the chance to exercise their right to a self-determined life in dignity and justice
Problems when changing internal causes (for example, unusable farmland)
Strengthening the manufacturing sector
Development aid such as debt relief is likely to reduce future financial aid, so developing countries benefit less than expected
Promoting equal rights
Less dependence on imports (terms of trade)
Developing countries can develop further with the money